diff --git a/docs/identified_problems.md b/docs/identified_problems.md index e1133a9..afac951 100644 --- a/docs/identified_problems.md +++ b/docs/identified_problems.md @@ -2,11 +2,12 @@ - [ ] In most of the components from 'models/' we have a method to add input and output to the model, however this linking of components is already done in oc-schedule when parsing the MxGraph. We need to determine if adding relations between components inside the objects themself is necessary. - When running in debug mode with a breakpoint inside the first line of computing.addLink it is only called once -- [ ] + ## MxGraph - [ ] The ConsumeMxGraphModel is way too long, it should refactored and broken down in different sub methods - mxcell are put inside an tag when the settings have been opened, wether values have been set or not. Maybe we could find a way to make mxgraph add these whenever we add a component to the graph. - then identify the links only -- [ ] It is unclear what are the inputs and the ouputs. It seems like they were implemented to link two components, but it seems redundant with the identification of links \ No newline at end of file +- [ ] It is unclear what are the inputs and the ouputs. It seems like they were implemented to link two components, but it seems redundant with the identification of links + - This has been potentially tackled with the creation of a class to handle links between components. The components do no handle their own connections with other components, this task is delegated to the Link and Worlflow classes. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/linking_errors.md b/docs/linking_errors.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1cfcd2a --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/linking_errors.md @@ -0,0 +1,25 @@ +# Handling errors during workflows' post + +Every time an user modify a worflow through oc-search's GUI its representation is sent through an XML to oc-catalog API. + +To ensure a correct execution of the workflow we must look for irregularities in the workflow's design. Of course an error can be the result of a workflow being currently built by the user, with the corrective action coming. + +This document aims at laying down all the requirements that each component must respect and show wether they have been implemented in the code or not. + +## Computing + +- [x] A computing component must be paired with a datacenter component + +## Data + +- [x] A data component must be linked to at least one computing component + +## Datacenter + +- [x] A datacenter component must be linked to at least one computing component + +## Storage + +- [x] A storage component must have at least one target or be the source of another component + + diff --git a/models/links.go b/models/links.go index 5ad26f2..02ba8a7 100644 --- a/models/links.go +++ b/models/links.go @@ -14,17 +14,38 @@ type Link struct { // Use ResourceObject parameter to process certain components type differently // and Id's to identify each component as a node in an oriented graph -func NewLink(src ResourceObject, srcId string, dst ResourceObject, dstId string) (link Link) { +// In the case of DCLink we choose to always consider the DC as the destination +// in order to facilitate some logic +func NewLink(src ResourceObject, srcId string, dst ResourceObject, dstId string) (link Link) { link.Source = srcId link.Destination = dstId + // If the link is between a DC and a component make sure that the DC is destination + // and if the component is computing, update the DataCenterID + if (src.getRtype() == rtype.DATACENTER || dst.getRtype() == rtype.DATACENTER){ + var linked ResourceObject + link.DCLink = true + if src.getRtype() == rtype.DATACENTER { + linked = dst + } else { + linked = src + } + if( link.DCLink && src.getRtype() == rtype.DATACENTER){ + link.Destination = srcId + link.Source = dstId + } + + if (linked.getRtype() == rtype.COMPUTING){ + linked.(*ComputingObject).DataCenterID = link.Destination + } } - + + return } diff --git a/models/mxgraph.go b/models/mxgraph.go index 395dfe0..f30d7af 100644 --- a/models/mxgraph.go +++ b/models/mxgraph.go @@ -41,15 +41,35 @@ type MxObject struct { // Didn't manage to differentiate Links and cells containing components using // only structures and unmarshal, so we use this method post-umarshalling -func (g *MxGraphModel) createLinks() error { +func (g *MxGraphModel) createLinks() { + var cells_without_links []MxCell + + for i, mxcell := range g.Root.MxCell { - if mxcell.Edge != nil { + + if mxcell.Edge != nil { + mxcell.processLinks() newLink := MxLink{mxcell.ID,*mxcell.Source,*mxcell.Target} g.Root.MxLink = append(g.Root.MxLink,newLink) - g.Root.MxCell = append(g.Root.MxCell[:i],g.Root.MxCell[i+1:]...) + } else { + cells_without_links = append(cells_without_links,g.Root.MxCell[i]) } } - return nil + + + g.Root.MxCell = nil + g.Root.MxCell = cells_without_links + +} + +func (cell *MxCell) processLinks() { + v := "" + if cell.Source == nil { + cell.Source = &v + } + if cell.Target == nil { + cell.Target = &v + } } type mxissue struct { diff --git a/models/workflow.go b/models/workflow.go index 1fecb71..c0aff7f 100644 --- a/models/workflow.go +++ b/models/workflow.go @@ -546,12 +546,8 @@ func ParseMxGraph(username, workflowName, xmlData string) (err error, mxissues [ return err, nil } - err = xmlModel.createLinks() - if err != nil { - logs.Alert("Error creating links") - return err, nil - } - + xmlModel.createLinks() + targetWorkspaceWorkflow, err, mxissues := userWorkspace.ConsumeMxGraphModel(xmlModel) if err != nil { @@ -652,6 +648,23 @@ func (ws Workspace) ConsumeMxGraphModel(xmlmodel MxGraphModel) (returned_wf *Wor // issues = append(issues, errors.New("MxCell with ID "+cell.ID+" doesn't have a valid link")) default: + // Not root nor resource. Should be only links + sourceObj := returned_wf.GetResource(cell.Source) + targetObj := returned_wf.GetResource(cell.Target) + + if sourceObj == nil || targetObj == nil { + if sourceObj == nil && targetObj == nil { + issues = append(issues, errors.New("Arrow "+cell.ID+" is alone")) + } else if sourceObj == nil { + issues = append(issues, errors.New("Arrow ("+cell.ID+") to "+*targetObj.getName()+" without parent")) + } else { + issues = append(issues, errors.New("Arrow "+cell.ID+" from "+*sourceObj.getName()+" without target")) + } + + // If is a invalid link, we can't save it in the DB + continue + } + // Not root nor resource. Should be only links // If is a invalid link, we can't save it in the DB // We should always get a ID because we already registered resources and discarded which doesn't correspond to existent models @@ -665,58 +678,59 @@ func (ws Workspace) ConsumeMxGraphModel(xmlmodel MxGraphModel) (returned_wf *Wor } } - issues = ws.CreateLinks(returned_wf,xmlmodel.Root.MxLink, issues) + issues = returned_wf.CreateLinks(xmlmodel.Root.MxLink, issues) + issues = returned_wf.CheckLinks(issues) - dcslist := make(map[string]bool) - dataslist := make(map[string]bool) - // datalist := make(map[string]bool) + // dcslist := make(map[string]bool) + // dataslist := make(map[string]bool) + // // datalist := make(map[string]bool) - // Test wether the computing components are linked with a DC - for _, comp := range returned_wf.Computing { - if comp.DataCenterID == "" { - issues = append(issues, errors.New("Computing "+*comp.getName()+" without a Datacenter")) - } else { - // If doesn't exist in the list, means is new element to register as used - dcslist[comp.DataCenterID] = true + // // Test wether the computing components are linked with a DC + // for _, comp := range returned_wf.Computing { + // if comp.DataCenterID == "" { + // issues = append(issues, errors.New("Computing "+*comp.getName()+" without a Datacenter")) + // } else { + // // If doesn't exist in the list, means is new element to register as used + // dcslist[comp.DataCenterID] = true - } + // } - for _, dcin := range comp.Inputs { - switch returned_wf.GetResource(&dcin).getRtype() { - case rtype.DATA: - dataslist[dcin] = true - } - } + // for _, dcin := range comp.Inputs { + // switch returned_wf.GetResource(&dcin).getRtype() { + // case rtype.DATA: + // dataslist[dcin] = true + // } + // } - for _, dcout := range comp.Outputs { - switch returned_wf.GetResource(&dcout).getRtype() { - case rtype.DATA: - dataslist[dcout] = true - } - } + // for _, dcout := range comp.Outputs { + // switch returned_wf.GetResource(&dcout).getRtype() { + // case rtype.DATA: + // dataslist[dcout] = true + // } + // } - } + // } - for _, storage_component := range returned_wf.Storage { - if storage_component.Inputs == nil && storage_component.Outputs == nil { - issues = append(issues, errors.New("Storage "+*storage_component.getName()+" without compatible inputs and outputs")) - } - } + // for _, storage_component := range returned_wf.Storage { + // if storage_component.Inputs == nil && storage_component.Outputs == nil { + // issues = append(issues, errors.New("Storage "+*storage_component.getName()+" without compatible inputs and outputs")) + // } + // } - for dcID, dc_component := range returned_wf.Datacenter { - // if rID doesn't exist in the list, it means that it's not used - if _, ok := dcslist[dcID]; !ok { - issues = append(issues, errors.New("DC "+*dc_component.getName()+" not atached to any Computing")) - } - } + // for dcID, dc_component := range returned_wf.Datacenter { + // // if rID doesn't exist in the list, it means that it's not used + // if _, ok := dcslist[dcID]; !ok { + // issues = append(issues, errors.New("DC "+*dc_component.getName()+" not attached to any Computing")) + // } + // } - for dcID, data_component := range returned_wf.Data { - // if rID doesn't exist in the list, it means that it's not used - if _, ok := dataslist[dcID]; !ok { - issues = append(issues, errors.New("Data "+*data_component.getName()+" not atached to any Computing")) - } - } + // for dcID, data_component := range returned_wf.Data { + // // if rID doesn't exist in the list, it means that it's not used + // if _, ok := dataslist[dcID]; !ok { + // issues = append(issues, errors.New("Data "+*data_component.getName()+" not attached to any Computing")) + // } + // } ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// // // @@ -819,57 +833,116 @@ func (ws Workspace) ConsumeMxGraphModel(xmlmodel MxGraphModel) (returned_wf *Wor return } -func (w Workspace) CreateLinks(returned_wf *Workflow, links []MxLink, issues []error) []error { +func (w *Workflow) CreateLinks(links []MxLink, issues []error) []error { for _, link := range links { - sourceObj := returned_wf.GetResource(&link.Source) - targetObj := returned_wf.GetResource(&link.Target) - - link_object := NewLink(sourceObj,link.Source, targetObj, link.Target) - returned_wf.AddLinkToWorkflow(link_object,link.ID) - - if sourceObj == nil || targetObj == nil { - if sourceObj == nil && targetObj == nil { - issues = append(issues, errors.New("Arrow "+link.ID +" is alone")) - } else if sourceObj == nil { - issues = append(issues, errors.New("Arrow ("+link.ID+") to "+*targetObj.getName()+" without parent")) - } else { - issues = append(issues, errors.New("Arrow "+link.ID+" from "+*sourceObj.getName()+" without target")) - } - + if (len(link.Source) > 0 && len(link.Target) > 0){ + sourceObj := w.GetResource(&link.Source) + targetObj := w.GetResource(&link.Target) + link_object := NewLink(sourceObj,link.Source, targetObj, link.Target) + w.AddLinkToWorkflow(link_object,link.ID) + } else { + issues = append(issues, w.processLinkErrors(link)) } - - - // if sourceObj.getRtype() == rtype.DATACENTER || targetObj.getRtype() == rtype.DATACENTER { - // var datacenter, datacenterLinked *string - - // if sourceObj.getRtype() == rtype.DATACENTER { - // datacenter = &link.Source - // datacenterLinked = &link.Target - // } else { - // datacenter = &link.Target - // datacenterLinked = &link.Source - // } - - // switch returned_wf.GetResource(datacenterLinked).getRtype() { - // case rtype.COMPUTING: - // computingObj := returned_wf.GetResource(datacenterLinked).(*ComputingObject) - - // computingObj.DataCenterID = *datacenter - // returned_wf.UpdateObj(computingObj, *datacenterLinked) - // } - - // } else { - // targetObj.addLink(INPUT, *link.Source) - // returned_wf.UpdateObj(targetObj, *link.Target) - - // sourceObj.addLink(OUTPUT, *link.Target) - // returned_wf.UpdateObj(sourceObj, *link.Source) - // } } return issues } +func (w *Workflow) processLinkErrors(link MxLink) (issue error) { + if len(link.Source) == 0 && len(link.Target) == 0 { + issue = errors.New("Arrow "+link.ID+" is alone") + } else if len(link.Source) == 0{ + targetObj := w.GetResource(&link.Target) + issue = errors.New("Arrow ("+link.ID+") to "+*targetObj.getName()+" without parent") + } else { + sourceObj := w.GetResource(&link.Source) + issue = errors.New("Arrow "+link.ID+" from "+*sourceObj.getName()+" without target") + } + + return issue +} + +func (w *Workflow) CheckLinks(issues []error) []error { + + // Check that storage components have a valid link + for id, storage := range w.Storage { + if(!w.IsComponentSrc(id) && !w.IsComponentDst(id)){ + issues = append(issues, errors.New("Storage "+*storage.getName()+" without compatible inputs and outputs")) + } + } + + // Check that data components are linked to a computing component + for id, data := range w.Data { + if(!w.HasLinkageToComputing(id)){ + issues = append(issues, errors.New("Data "+*data.getName()+" not attached to any Computing")) + } + } + + // Check that DC is linked to a computing component + for id, dc:= range w.Datacenter { + if(!w.HasLinkageToComputing(id)){ + issues = append(issues, errors.New("Datacenter "+*dc.getName()+" not attached to any Computing")) + } + + } + + // Check that all data computing components are linked to a DC + for id,comp:= range w.Computing { + if(!w.HasLinkageToDC(id)){ + issues = append(issues, errors.New("Computing "+*comp.getName()+" not attached to any datacenter")) + } + + } + + return issues +} + + +func (w *Workflow) IsComponentSrc(id string) bool { + + for _, link := range w.Links{ + if(link.Source == id && link.Source != ""){ + return true + } + } + + return false +} + +func (w *Workflow) IsComponentDst(id string) bool { + + for _, link := range w.Links{ + if(link.Destination == id && link.Source != ""){ + return true + } + } + + return false +} + +func (w *Workflow) HasLinkageToComputing(id string) bool { + + for idComputing, _ := range w.Computing { + if( (w.IsComponentSrc(id) && w.IsComponentDst(idComputing)) || (w.IsComponentSrc(idComputing) && w.IsComponentDst(id))){ + return true + } + + } + + return false +} + +func (w *Workflow) HasLinkageToDC(id string) bool { + + for _, link := range w.Links{ + if(link.Source == id && link.DCLink){ + return true + } + } + + return false +} + func sumExecutionReqs(exeqReq ...ExecutionRequirementsModel) (ret ExecutionRequirementsModel) { for _, v := range exeqReq { ret.CPUs += v.CPUs